Coleslaw with a Creamy Dressing and Pepper Bite

I’ve made coleslaw dozens of ways—soggy, overly sweet, weirdly bland—but this version hits different. You get that crispy cabbage texture that actually survives the fridge, paired with a creamy dressing that doesn’t feel like you’re eating mayonnaise straight from the jar. The real magic happens when you nail the balance between tangy and slightly sweet. Want to know the secret ingredient that transforms basic cabbage into something your family will actually request?

Why You’ll Love this coleslaw

Whether you’re bringing a side dish to a potluck or just tired of the same old salad routine, this coleslaw’s got your back. I love how it’s creamy without feeling heavy, and that crunch stays perfect even after sitting in the fridge.

The vinegar gives it just enough tang to cut through richness, while the celery seeds add this subtle flavor I can’t quite put my finger on but definitely makes it special. Plus, it’s ridiculously easy to throw together. No fancy knife skills needed, honestly. You shred, dice, mix, and done.

Also read: Buttery Cabbage & Bacon Recipe

What Ingredients are in coleslaw?

Making homemade coleslaw requires just a handful of simple, straightforward ingredients that you likely already have in your kitchen. The beauty of this recipe lies in its simplicity—there’s no need for obscure items or specialty products.

Each ingredient plays an important role in creating that perfect balance of creamy texture, tangy flavor, and satisfying crunch that makes this coleslaw so irresistible.

• 1/2 head cabbage
• 1 medium carrot
• 1/2 cup onion (diced)
• 2 cups mayonnaise
• 2 tablespoons white vinegar
• 2 teaspoons sugar
• 2 teaspoons celery seeds

When it comes to sweetener options, you have flexibility beyond regular sugar. Honey and xylitol both work as excellent substitutes, with xylitol being particularly useful if you’re cooking for someone with diabetes since it tastes virtually identical to sugar in this recipe.

Honey will impart a slightly different flavor profile but remains delicious. If you prefer a more pronounced tang, don’t hesitate to increase the vinegar or celery seed quantities to suit your taste preferences—these adjustments allow you to customize the coleslaw to your exact liking without compromising the recipe’s integrity.

How to Make this coleslaw

• Begin by preparing your vegetables. Shred 1/2 head of cabbage to your preferred thickness—finer shreds create a more delicate texture, while chunkier pieces offer more bite.
• Shred 1 medium carrot using the same method, then dice 1/2 cup of onion into small, uniform pieces. Set these vegetables aside in a large mixing bowl.
• In a separate bowl, combine your dressing ingredients: 2 cups mayonnaise, 2 tablespoons white vinegar, 2 teaspoons sugar, and 2 teaspoons celery seeds.
• Whisk these together until well blended and smooth. Pour the dressing over the cabbage, carrot, and onion mixture, then toss everything together until all the vegetables are evenly coated and incorporated with the creamy dressing.
• Transfer your coleslaw to the refrigerator and allow it to marinate for at least an hour, though leaving it overnight or for up to a day will develop deeper flavors and help the vegetables become more tender.
• The longer marinating time also allows the vegetables to release their natural juices, which blend beautifully with the dressing. Once properly chilled and marinated, your homemade coleslaw is ready to serve alongside your favorite BBQ, sandwiches, or main dishes.

Coleslaw with a Creamy Dressing and Pepper Bite

Crispy cabbage texture survives the fridge paired with creamy dressing that doesn't feel heavy, balanced with tangy vinegar and celery seeds that add subtle flavor. This ridiculously easy coleslaw transforms shredded vegetables into something your family will actually request, with crunch that stays perfect even after days of refrigeration.

Print Recipe Pin Recipe

Prep Time 15 minutes mins

Chilling time 1 hour hr

Servings: 8

Course: Side Dish

Cuisine: American

Calories: 385

Ingredients Method Notes

Ingredients

  

• 1/2 head cabbage
• 1 medium carrot
• 1/2 cup onion diced
• 2 cups mayonnaise
• 2 tablespoons white vinegar
• 2 teaspoons sugar
• 2 teaspoons celery seeds

Method

 

1. Begin by preparing your vegetables. Shred 1/2 head of cabbage to your preferred thickness—finer shreds create a more delicate texture, while chunkier pieces offer more bite.
2. Shred 1 medium carrot using the same method, then dice 1/2 cup of onion into small, uniform pieces. Set these vegetables aside in a large mixing bowl.
3. In a separate bowl, combine your dressing ingredients: 2 cups mayonnaise, 2 tablespoons white vinegar, 2 teaspoons sugar, and 2 teaspoons celery seeds.
4. Whisk these together until well blended and smooth. Pour the dressing over the cabbage, carrot, and onion mixture, then toss everything together until all the vegetables are evenly coated and incorporated with the creamy dressing.
5. Transfer your coleslaw to the refrigerator and allow it to marinate for at least an hour, though leaving it overnight or for up to a day will develop deeper flavors and help the vegetables become more tender.
6. The longer marinating time also allows the vegetables to release their natural juices, which blend beautifully with the dressing. Once properly chilled and marinated, your homemade coleslaw is ready to serve alongside your favorite BBQ, sandwiches, or main dishes.

Notes

What to Serve with Coleslaw

Since coleslaw’s crispy, tangy nature makes it pretty versatile, you’ve got plenty of options for what to pair it with. I’d serve it alongside pulled pork sandwiches, where that cool crunch cuts through the richness perfectly.

BBQ ribs? Absolutely, coleslaw’s like the perfect sidekick there. Fish tacos become something special when you pile this on top, and burgers frankly need it. Even fried chicken benefits from that vinegary bite.

You could throw it on hot dogs, nachos, or use it as a topping for grilled fish. The possibilities honestly feel endless once you start thinking creatively about it.

coleslaw Substitutions and Variations

Once you’ve mastered the basic coleslaw recipe, you’ll probably start wondering what happens if you tinker with it a bit. I’d swap sugar for honey or xylitol—both work beautifully, though honey shifts the flavor slightly while xylitol keeps things tasting identical.

Perfect for diabetic friends at your table. Want more personality? Crank up the vinegar or celery seeds for serious bite. The beauty here is flexibility. You’re not locked into one version. Since I don’t consider artificial sweeteners safe options, these swaps feel like genuine improvements rather than compromises. Your coleslaw becomes uniquely yours.

What to Serve with coleslaw

Since coleslaw’s crispy, tangy nature makes it pretty versatile, you’ve got plenty of options for what to pair it with. I’d serve it alongside pulled pork sandwiches, where that cool crunch cuts through the richness perfectly.

BBQ ribs? Absolutely, coleslaw’s like the perfect sidekick there. Fish tacos become something special when you pile this on top, and burgers frankly need it. Even fried chicken benefits from that vinegary bite.

You could throw it on hot dogs, nachos, or use it as a topping for grilled fish. The possibilities honestly feel endless once you start thinking creatively about it.

Final Thoughts

So you’ve got all these amazing dishes that’d benefit from a crispy, tangy coleslaw topping, and now you’re probably wondering if this recipe’s actually worth the effort, right. I’m telling you, it absolutely is. This coleslaw comes together in minutes, and the flavor payoff? Ridiculous. You’ll find yourself making it constantly because it’s that good. The best part is how versatile it becomes with simple tweaks—want more bite, add vinegar; prefer it sweeter, swap sugar for honey. Your family will genuinely ask for seconds, and honestly, that’s the real test of any recipe’s success.